Question 170: Magnetism and Matter

Question

A square loop of side 2$$a$$ and carrying current I is kept in xz plane with its centre at origin. A long
wire carrying the same current I is placed parallel to z-axis and passing through point (0, b, 0),
(b >> a). The magnitude of torque on the loop about z-axis will be :

Accepted Answer

First, let's consider the magnetic field created by the long wire carrying a current $I$ at a distance $b$. According to Ampere's Law, the magnetic field $B$ at a distance $b$ from a long straight wire is given by:
$$B = \frac{{\mu_0 I}}{{2\pi b}}$$
where $\mu_0$ is the permeability of free space.
Given that the square loop of side $2a$ is carrying the same current $I$ and is located in the xz-plane with its center at the origin, we can analyze the forces on each side of the loop. The sides of the loop parallel to the x-axis will experience forces due to the magnetic field from the long wire. Considering symmetry and the directions of forces, the net force on these sides will not contribute to the torque around the z-axis.
The contribution to the torque around the z-axis will predominantly come from the sides of the loop parallel to the y-axis. For these sides, the magnetic forces will be in opposite directions and will create a torque around the z-axis.
Let's calculate the forces on the sides parallel to the y-axis. For a current element $Idl$ in the presence of a magnetic field $B$, the force $dF$ is given by:
$$dF = I dl 	imes B$$
For the sides at $x = a$ and $x = -a$, the distances to the wire are $a + b$ and $a - b$, respectively.
The magnetic fields at these positions due to the long wire are:
For $x = a$:
$$B_a = \frac{{\mu_0 I}}{{2 \pi (a+b)}}$$
For $x = -a$:
$$B_{-a} = \frac{{\mu_0 I}}{{2 \pi (a-b)}}$$
Since $b \gg a$, we can approximate these fields using binomial expansion for small $\left(\frac{a}{b}ight)$:
$$B_a \approx \frac{{\mu_0 I}}{{2 \pi b}} \left(1 - \frac{a}{b}ight)$$
$$B_{-a} \approx \frac{{\mu_0 I}}{{2 \pi b}} \left(1 + \frac{a}{b}ight)$$
The forces on each side of the loop with length $2a$ are:
For $x = a$:
$$F_a = I \cdot 2a \cdot B_a = I \cdot 2a \cdot \frac{{\mu_0 I}}{{2 \pi b}} \left(1 - \frac{a}{b}ight)$$
For $x = -a$:
$$F_{-a} = I \cdot 2a \cdot B_{-a} = I \cdot 2a \cdot \frac{{\mu_0 I}}{{2 \pi b}} \left(1 + \frac{a}{b}ight)$$
The net torque $	au$ around the z-axis is due to these forces, with lever arms $a$ and $-a$ respectively:
$$	au = 2a \left( F_a - F_{-a} ight)$$
Substituting the expressions for $F_a$ and $F_{-a}$:
$$	au = 2a \left[ I \cdot 2a \cdot \frac{{\mu_0 I}}{{2 \pi b}} \left(1 - \frac{a}{b}ight) - I \cdot 2a \cdot \frac{{\mu_0 I}}{{2 \pi b}} \left(1 + \frac{a}{b}ight) ight]$$
Simplifying this expression, we get:
$$	au = 2a \left[ 2a I \cdot \frac{{\mu_0 I}}{{2 \pi b}} \left( -\frac{2a}{b} ight) ight]$$
$$	au = -2a \cdot \frac{{4a^2 \mu_0 I^2}}{{2 \pi b^2}}$$
The negative sign indicates the direction of the torque, but the magnitude is:
$$	au = \frac{{4a^3 \mu_0 I^2}}{{\pi b^2}}$$
Since $a \ll b$, the approximate magnitude of the torque around the z-axis simplifies to:
$$	au = \frac{{2 \mu_0 I^2 a^2}}{{\pi b}}$$
Therefore, the correct answer is:
Option A
$$\frac{{2\mu_0 I^2 a^2}}{{\pi b}}$$

Answer

$${{2{\mu _0}{I^2}{a^2}} \over {\pi b}}$$

Answer

$${{2{\mu _0}{I^2}{a^2}b} \over {\pi \left( {{a^2} + {b^2}} \right)}}$$

Answer

$${{{\mu _0}{I^2}{a^2}b} \over {2\pi \left( {{a^2} + {b^2}} \right)}}$$

Answer

$${{{\mu _0}{I^2}{a^2}} \over {2\pi b}}$$

Magnetism and Matter

A square loop of side 2$a$ and carrying current I is kept in xz plane with its centre at origin. A long wire carrying the same current I is placed parallel to z-axis and passing through point (0, b, 0), (b >> a). The magnitude of torque on the loop about z-axis will be :

Choose the correct answer: